Select raw retail weight or plain cooked portion (accounting for cooking shrinkage).
Best value lean steak with bold beef flavor and high protein density
The most tender cut on the animal — buttery texture, mild flavor, premium price
Adjust serving size to scale all micronutrients, amino acids, and cost calculations.
Enter your local grocery shelf prices to calculate true serving economics and cost per gram of protein.
Results & Head-to-Head Comparison
Portion: 150 g (150g raw)Top Sirloin Steak (Lean)
Serving: 150 g (150g raw)
Tenderloin Filet Mignon
Serving: 150 g (150g raw)
Official FDA Nutrition Facts Panel (Side-by-Side)
Standardized regulatory nutrition labels scaled dynamically for your 150 g (150g raw) serving.
Macronutrient & Lipid Profile Breakdown
Detailed comparison of calories, protein content, and saturated vs monounsaturated fatty acids for 150 g (150g raw).
Fatty Acid Sub-Fractions (Lipid Architecture)
Sirloin vs Tenderloin: Nutrition, Tenderness & Cost Guide
Top sirloin and filet mignon (beef tenderloin) are both premium whole-muscle steaks—but they occupy opposite ends of the beef value spectrum. Top sirloin delivers bolder beef flavor, higher cooked protein density (29.5g vs 26.1g per 100g), and typically costs 60% to 70% less per pound. Filet mignon is the most tender muscle on the animal, prized for its mild, buttery texture in fine dining and special-occasion plates. The choice is rarely about which is “healthier”—it is about matching tenderness expectations, budget, and cooking method to your goal.
vs $25–$35/lb for filet mignon
vs 26.1g for broiled tenderloin
Both exceed 15% DV per 100g
USDA minimum 145°F + 3 min rest
Sirloin vs Tenderloin: Goal-Based Matchups
Compare matched cuts and prep bases—not generic steak averages—to get accurate macro, tenderness, and cost data.
Top Sirloin vs Filet Mignon
Raw top sirloin (183 kcal, 27g protein, 7.6g fat) is leaner than tenderloin (227 kcal, 21g protein, 15g fat). After broiling, sirloin concentrates to 187 kcal with 29.5g protein per 100g; tenderloin yields 217 kcal with 26.1g protein. Sirloin wins on protein density and cost; filet wins on tenderness and mild flavor.
Tri-Tip vs Filet Mignon
Tri-tip delivers robust sirloin-family flavor with strong protein density at a lower price point than center-cut filet. Cooked tri-tip provides ~28g protein per 100g with slightly more fat than top sirloin. Filet mignon offers easier chewing but lower protein per calorie—ideal for recovery meals when texture matters more than maximum grams per dollar.
NY Strip vs Filet Mignon
NY strip (strip steak) balances marbling and chew with ~26g cooked protein per 100g. Filet mignon is the gold standard for tenderness in steakhouse menus and beef Wellington. Strip offers more beef-forward flavor at ~40% lower cost; filet delivers the melt-in-your-mouth experience diners expect for celebrations.
Flank Steak vs Filet Mignon
Flank is the most affordable sirloin-family alternative (~$8–$12/lb) with 27.7g cooked protein per 100g when sliced against the grain. Marinated flank closes much of the tenderness gap with filet at one-third the price. Reserve filet mignon for dishes where whole-muscle tenderness cannot be replaced by slicing technique.
Tenderness, Cost & Nutrition Trade-Offs
Cost & Protein Economics
Tenderloin represents only 2% to 3% of carcass yield, driving retail prices to $25–$35/lb versus ~$10/lb for top sirloin. After cooking shrinkage (~18% for both cuts), sirloin typically delivers protein at $0.06 to $0.08 per gram versus $0.15 to $0.22 for filet mignon—making sirloin the clear winner for high-volume meal prep and family grilling.
Nutrition & Micronutrient Density
Both cuts provide complete protein, heme iron (15–35% absorption), zinc, vitamin B12, creatine, and carnosine. Cooked sirloin edges zinc (5.6mg vs 5.1mg per 100g); tenderloin edges iron slightly (2.6mg vs 2.0mg). Neither is nutritionally inferior—the macro difference is modest compared to the tenderness and cost gap.
Texture & Culinary Applications
Sirloin-family cuts (top sirloin, tri-tip, strip, flank) suit grilling, pan-searing, stir-fry, and steak salads. Tenderloin excels in beef Wellington, whole-roast presentations, and dishes where extreme tenderness is non-negotiable. Marinating sirloin and slicing against the grain closes much of the texture gap for everyday cooking.
Anatomical Difference
Tenderloin runs along the spine inside the short loin and rib— a muscle that does minimal work, producing fine grain and low connective tissue. Top sirloin comes from the hip region with slightly more connective tissue and stronger myoglobin-driven flavor. See our Sirloin Nutrition Tool and Tenderloin Nutrition Tool for cut-specific USDA data.
Safe Cooking Temperatures: Sirloin vs Filet Mignon
Top sirloin, tri-tip, strip, and flank are intact whole-muscle cuts. USDA FSIS allows 145°F with a 3-minute rest because surface bacteria are killed by high-heat searing. Chefs often pull sirloin at 130–135°F for medium-rare carryover.
Tenderloin's low intramuscular fat means it dries quickly past medium. Chefs typically pull filets at 125°F for carryover to 130–135°F. USDA minimum remains 145°F with rest. Avoid overcooking—filet loses its signature texture rapidly above 140°F internal.
Sirloin vs Tenderloin: Frequently Asked Questions
Evidence-based answers on nutrition, tenderness, portioning, cost, and cooking technique.
Is sirloin as good as tenderloin (filet mignon)?
Sirloin and tenderloin serve different purposes. Top sirloin delivers stronger beef flavor, higher cooked protein density (29.5g vs 26.1g per 100g cooked), and costs roughly 60% to 70% less per pound. Filet mignon is the most tender muscle on the animal with a mild, buttery texture prized for fine dining. Many steak lovers prefer sirloin for everyday meals; tenderloin wins for special occasions and dishes requiring melt-in-your-mouth texture like beef Wellington.
Which is leaner: sirloin or filet mignon?
On a raw per-100g basis, top sirloin is leaner (183 kcal, 7.6g fat) than tenderloin (227 kcal, 15g fat). After cooking, sirloin concentrates to 187 kcal with 6.7g fat per 100g, while broiled tenderloin yields 217 kcal with 11.8g fat. For strict macro tracking, top sirloin is the leaner choice; trimmed center-cut filet can approach similar leanness but retail filets often include chain muscle fat.
Can I substitute sirloin for filet mignon in recipes?
For grilling, pan-searing, and steak salads, top sirloin is an excellent substitute at a fraction of the cost. For recipes demanding extreme tenderness without slicing technique (beef Wellington, tartare-style preparations, or whole-roast presentation), tenderloin is difficult to replace. Marinating sirloin and slicing against the grain closes much of the texture gap.
Which has more protein, sirloin or tenderloin?
Cooked top sirloin leads with approximately 29.5g protein per 100g versus 26.1g for broiled tenderloin. Raw values are closer (27g sirloin vs 21g tenderloin per 100g) because sirloin loses less moisture during cooking. A 170g (6 oz) cooked sirloin portion delivers about 50g protein; the same weight of cooked filet delivers about 44g.
Why is filet mignon so much more expensive than sirloin?
Tenderloin represents only 2% to 3% of the carcass weight and sits inside the short loin without much exercise, producing unmatched tenderness but limited yield per animal. Top sirloin comes from a larger, more active muscle with slightly more connective tissue but far greater supply. Retail benchmarks: sirloin ~$10/lb vs filet mignon ~$25–$35/lb.
Does sirloin or tenderloin have more iron and zinc?
Both are excellent heme iron sources. Cooked top sirloin provides ~2.0mg iron and 5.6mg zinc per 100g. Cooked tenderloin provides ~2.6mg iron and 5.1mg zinc per 100g. Tenderloin edges iron slightly; sirloin edges zinc. Both exceed 15% DV for iron and nearly 50% DV for zinc in a typical 6 oz serving.
What doneness is best for sirloin vs filet mignon?
Both cuts shine at medium-rare (130–135°F internal) where myosin denaturation is minimal and juices remain. Sirloin tolerates medium (140°F) well due to slightly more connective tissue. Filet mignon dries quickly past medium because of its low intramuscular fat — chefs typically pull filets at 125°F for carryover cooking. USDA minimum for intact steaks is 145°F with a 3-minute rest.
Should I compare sirloin and tenderloin raw or cooked?
Use raw mode when weighing meat before cooking for macro tracking — USDA FoodData Central benchmarks uncooked weight. Use cooked mode when portioning after grilling or broiling. Sirloin shrinks ~18% during broiling; tenderloin shrinks ~18% at medium-rare. Always compare both cuts on the same prep basis for accurate results.
Nutrition values are derived from USDA FoodData Central source records (FDC IDs cited in the comparison tool). Price benchmarks reflect USDA ERS retail spreads and are planning estimates—not live store quotes. Last reviewed September 2026.
Related tools
Ribeye vs Sirloin
Compare ribeye and sirloin steak for calories, protein, fat, marbling, tenderness, cooking fit, and price.
Sirloin vs Flank Steak
Compare sirloin and flank steak for calories, protein, fat, texture, grilling fit, and price.
Ribeye vs Tenderloin
Compare ribeye and tenderloin for calories, protein, fat, tenderness, and price.
New York Strip vs Ribeye
Compare NY Strip and Ribeye for nutrition, marbling, tenderness, flavor, cooking methods, and price.
Beef Cuts Explained
Master guide to 8 primal beef cuts, butcher anatomy, tenderness ratings, and cooking methods.